Nico Muhly on Understory by Thomas Bartlett

By way of introducing the forthcoming Thomas Bartlett album Understory to listeners, Nico Muhly shared his personal response to the album, as one of Bartlett’s longtime friends and collaborators:

Understory is a collection of ten pieces for solo piano which exist on the knife’s-edge between freeform music, ambient music, and more traditional compositions. Each piece poses its own questions about structure, form, and melody. One pathway through the album is to imagine that the pieces have their own footprint or gait, and their own private mechanisms. For instance, the first track, Nitida is a piece of music whose refrain and motor is signaled by two simple notes just a tenth away from one another. That becomes less a theme than an idée fixe. The fifth track, Pendulina, and the final track, Alba, are the only other pieces with a more formal relationship to traditional songwriting — most of the pieces don’t end remotely where they began, immediately confounding our sense of how music should be organized, but without a premium put on surprises and sudden changes of tack, or, indeed, the sudden recognition of the tune, returning home from the rumspringa of improvisation. This music is deliberate and curious.

I found myself thinking of these pieces like the local characters in one’s neighborhood whose names we never learn, and whose stories are only barely glimpsed through subtle cues: an outlandishly expensive shoe with a humble jean; the woman who speaks fluent Chinese and Dominican-inflected Spanish in the same conversation, the man who stands outside smoking with his hands crossed behind his back and never speaking to anyone. These aren’t people without the formal rituals of life, but their narratives are somehow obscured, which becomes part of their mystical significance.

Listening through Understory, one can find oneself both allured and transported. Take, for instance, the opening of Villosa. The motion of the left hand of the piano form the governing footprint of the piece, and the opening tune is exactly that: a tune you could sing to your friend to remember how the piece goes. However, the agenda of the piece becomes unclear: this isn’t so much a chorus or a verse as a timepiece the character seems to consult from time to time — checking in with the folks at home while on a long, open-ended ticket elsewhere.

Thomas Bartlett. Photo credit: York Tillyer.

Improvised music is often subjected to the sort of nerdy (often posthumous) rigorous analysis normally reserved for advanced physics: California-sober men, somehow still with soul patches, arguing over the meaning of a slipped finger in a Keith Jarrett improvisation, or trying to tease out the cantus firmus in one of Ornette Coleman’s more impenetrable recordings. With Understory, each track seems to actively resist this kind of analysis: does it matter that it’s starts like an Irish folksong with a clear phrase structure, and then lands somewhere equally lyrical but completely divorced from the original homebase? There is something for everyone here, but in a way that makes you wonder who the other people are.

I thought, when listening, of the man who, night after night, started adding small objects to the grate around a neighborhood tree: at first a few rocks which he’d painted red, then some small, empty birdcages, followed by small plastic birds superglued in and onto the cages, salvaged pieces of concrete. Each addition seemed both inevitable and surprising in equal measure, and because it happened in the middle of the night, it had the power of a weather system moving in slowly rather than the drama of a sudden storm. I have no interest in finding out his backstory, because the beauty of it is the thing he does. It’s non-linear to the casual viewer, but he is somebody moving through life with a private itinerary, unclear motivations, and a beautiful and ephemeral result. The city tore it down in 2011.

Thomas has, in Understory, created an absolutely mesmerizing and unclassifiable set of pieces redolent of improvisation (as indeed they must have been created, and I don’t care), but chastened by an invisible logic and ability to follow his nose through familiar and uncharted territory over the course of the same leisurely walk.

Nico Muhly

Featured release

  • Understory

    Thomas Bartlett

    Released 08 January 2027

    Understory is a collection of ten mesmerizing solo piano pieces, recorded in London in March 2026. A sequel to his album Shelter, it finds Thomas Bartlett more settled, turning inward to wander beneath conscious thought. The felt-damped piano lends a richer, woodier, more organic sound as the music follows hidden paths through familiar and uncharted territory alike.

By Nico Muhly

Nico Muhly is an American composer and longtime friend and collaborator of Thomas Bartlett.

Published on Wed, 28 October 26

Further Reading

The Gloaming at the National Concert Hall: ‘An experiment in controlled happenstance’

A closer look at the phenomenon that is The Gloaming's annual sold-out residency at the NCH, Dublin.

Exploring the musical dialogue of Caoimhín Ó Raghallaigh & Thomas Bartlett’s debut album

Sophie Harris speaks to The Gloaming's Caoimhín Ó Raghallaigh and Thomas Bartlett about their new...

Novelist Michael Cunningham previews new Caoimhín Ó Raghallaigh & Thomas Bartlett album

The Pulitzer Prize winning novelist shares his thoughts on the beautiful new album.